Bare Ownership and Usufruct in Spain: A Guide for Expats

🇪🇸 Read the original in Spanish

In the Spanish real estate market, property ownership is not always a single, indivisible concept. Frequently, following an inheritance, a divorce, or as a financial planning strategy for retirement, we find that the ownership of a home is divided into two distinct and concurrent derechos reales (property rights): nuda propiedad (bare ownership) and usufructo (usufruct). Understanding the difference between who holds the legal title of owner and who has the right to enjoy the home is essential to avoid family conflicts, optimize taxation, and carry out secure transactions under the Spanish legal framework.

What are bare ownership and usufruct? Concept and legal framework

To understand these concepts, we must turn to the Spanish Civil Code (Código Civil), which regulates property and its divisions. Full ownership (pleno dominio) is the sum of two elements:

• La nuda propiedad (Bare ownership): This is the right of ownership over the asset, but without the right of use and enjoyment. The nudo propietario (bare owner) is the owner of the property, but cannot live in it, rent it out, or receive its fruits.
• El usufructo (Usufruct): Defined in Article 467 of the Civil Code, it is the right to enjoy third-party assets with the obligation to preserve their form and substance, unless the title of its constitution or the law authorizes otherwise. The usufructuario (usufructuary) has possession, use, and the right to obtain yields (for example, rental income) from the property.

This division can originate by law (such as the usufructo viudal / widowed spouse's usufruct in mutual agreement inheritances) or voluntarily (through a sale of bare ownership or a donation with reservation of usufruct).

Rights and duties of the bare owner and the usufructuary

The coexistence of these two rights over the same property often generates doubts regarding who must bear the costs, who can make decisions, and what legal limits exist. The Civil Code precisely defines these attributions.

Rights and obligations of the usufructuary

The usufructuary is the possessor of the home and has a series of clear powers and limits:

• Right of use and enjoyment: They can inhabit the property or, according to Article 480 of the Civil Code, lease it to third parties and receive the rental income in its entirety.
• Duration: If the usufruct is vitalicio (lifetime — the most common type), it is extinguished only upon the death of the usufructuary. If it is temporary, it will expire when the agreed term is met.
• Obligation of preservation: They must care for the property like a "good family father" (buen padre de familia) and carry out ordinary repairs resulting from wear and tear from daily use.
• Payment of current taxes: They are responsible for paying the taxes levied on the use of the assets, such as the Impuesto sobre Bienes Inmuebles (IBI / property tax) —unless agreed otherwise— and rubbish collection fees, in addition to utilities (water, electricity, gas).

Rights and obligations of the bare owner

The bare owner holds the legal title, but their capacity to act is limited so as not to disturb the usufruct:

• Right of disposal: They can sell the bare ownership to a third party or mortgage it (according to Article 107.2 of the Mortgage Law / Ley Hipotecaria), but the new acquirer must respect the existing usufruct until its extinction.
• Extraordinary works and repairs: The bare owner must take charge of extraordinary repairs (for example, repairing the structure of the building or the facade). According to the Civil Code, the usufructuary must notify them of the urgency of these works.
• Extraordinary community expenses: The derramas (special community assessments) approved by the homeowners' association (comunidad de propietarios) for structural improvements or the installation of a lift correspond to the bare owner.

The relationship with rentals and the Urban Leasing Act (LAU)

One of the most frequent questions is whether a usufructuary can rent out the property and what happens to that contract if the usufructuary passes away.

Under Law 29/1994 on Urban Leases (LAU - Ley de Arrendamientos Urbanos), the usufructuary has the full right to lease the property without needing the consent of the bare owner. However, Article 13.2 of the LAU establishes a golden rule: leases entered into by the usufructuary will terminate at the end of the landlord's right (that is, when the usufructuary dies or the temporary usufruct expires).

Therefore, the tenant must know that their rental contract may end early if the usufructuary who rented it to them dies, with the property passing to the bare owner free of rental encumbrances, unless the latter decides to ratify the contract.

Practical step-by-step steps for the sale of bare ownership

The sale of bare ownership is a booming financial formula in Spain, especially for people over 65 years of age who wish to obtain liquidity without leaving their home. These are the steps to carry out this process with full legal security:

1. Property valuation and usufruct calculation: The property must be appraised at market value. Subsequently, the value of the bare ownership and the usufruct is calculated using the official tax formula (the rule of 89).
2. Negotiation of conditions: It is agreed whether the payment will be made in a single lump sum (capital) or through a lifetime monthly annuity (renta vitalicia), and it is precisely defined who will bear the ordinary and extraordinary community expenses.
3. Drafting the contract and signing the Public Deed: It is essential to go to a Notario (Notary) to grant the public deed of sale of the bare ownership with reservation of lifetime usufruct.
4. Tax settlement: The buyer and the seller must settle the corresponding taxes within a maximum period of 30 business days from the signing.
5. Registration in the Property Registry: The deed is presented to the Registro de la Propiedad (Property Registry) so that the bare ownership is registered in the name of the buyer and the usufruct in the name of the seller, guaranteeing protection against third parties.

Deadlines, amounts and key figures: How is the value calculated?

To determine the tax and market value of bare ownership and lifetime usufruct, Spanish tax legislation (Impuesto sobre Sucesiones y Donaciones / Inheritance and Gift Tax, and Impuesto sobre Transmisiones Patrimoniales / Transfer Tax) applies the rule of 89.

• The value of the lifetime usufruct is equal to 89 minus the age of the usufructuary.
• The minimum percentage of the usufruct is 10% of the total value of the property (which is reached at 79 years of age) and the maximum is 70% (for those under 20 years of age).
• The value of the bare ownership is the remaining difference to complete 100% of the property's value.

Calculation example:

If a 75-year-old person sells the bare ownership of their home valued at €200,000:

• Value of the usufruct: 89 - 75 = 14% of the total value.
• Amount of the usufruct: €200,000 x 14% = €28,000.
• Value of the bare ownership: 100% - 14% = 86%.
• Amount of the bare ownership: €200,000 x 86% = €172,000.

Concrete real-life examples

Example 1: The usufructuary's rental

María, aged 82, is the lifetime usufructuary of an apartment in Madrid following the death of her husband. The bare owners are her two children. As María is moving to a care home, she decides to rent out the apartment for €1,200 per month to a third party to pay for her place.

Under the Civil Code, María does not need her children's permission to rent out the home, and the €1,200 monthly rent belongs entirely to her. However, if María dies two years later, the rental contract will be automatically terminated according to the LAU, and her children will recover full ownership of the property, being able to require the tenant to vacate the premises.

Example 2: Sale of bare ownership with a monthly annuity

Juan, aged 70, lives alone in an apartment valued at €300,000 in Barcelona. His pension is low and he wants to supplement his income. He sells the bare ownership to an investor for an initial payment of €50,000 plus a lifetime annuity of €600 per month, reserving the lifetime usufruct for himself.

Juan continues to live in his home for life, without paying rent. The investor (bare owner) assumes the payment of the community derramas of €1,500 for the repair of the building's entrance, while Juan continues to pay the electricity, water bills, and the rubbish collection fee.

Mistakes you should avoid

• Not putting the detailed breakdown of expenses in writing: Although the Civil Code establishes general rules, failing to detail in the notary deed who pays the IBI, the ordinary community fees, or the home insurance is often a source of legal disputes.
• Ignoring the impact on Personal Income Tax (IRPF): If you sell the bare ownership being under 65 years of age, the capital gain will be taxed under IRPF (Personal Income Tax). If you are over 65 years of age, the sale of the bare ownership of your primary residence (vivienda habitual) is exempt from taxation.
• Renting without clear termination clauses: If you are a tenant and sign a contract with a usufructuary, you must demand that this condition be specified in the contract to avoid surprises and unexpected evictions if the usufructuary dies.
• Not registering the usufruct in the Property Registry: If the usufruct is not formally registered, the bare owner could sell the property to a third party in good faith, which would generate serious legal security problems for the usufructuary.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Can the bare owner sell the property without the consent of the usufructuary?

Yes, the bare owner can sell the bare ownership to a third party without the consent of the usufructuary. However, the buyer must obligatorily respect the existing usufruct right. The usufructuary will continue living in the house or renting it out exactly the same as before the change of owner.

Who must pay the Property Tax (IBI) and the community fees?

As a general rule and according to the jurisprudence of the Supreme Court, the payment of the IBI and the ordinary community expenses correspond to the usufructuary, as they are the one who enjoys the services of the property. However, extraordinary community derramas correspond to the bare owner. It should be noted that the parties can agree otherwise in the deed of constitution.

How is the usufruct extinguished and full ownership consolidated?

The usufruct is extinguished mainly by the death of the usufructuary, by the expiration of the term if it was temporary, or by the renunciation of the usufructuary themselves. To consolidate full ownership in the name of the bare owner, the death certificate of the usufructuary must be presented to the Notary and the Transfer Tax or Inheritance Tax must be settled to register the extinction in the Property Registry.

Can the usufructuary make renovations to the property?

The usufructuary can make improvements to the property provided they do not alter its form or substance (Article 487 of the Civil Code). They do not have the right to be indemnified by the bare owner for these improvements when the usufruct is extinguished, although they can remove them if it is possible to do so without causing damage to the property.

In summary

• Bare ownership (nuda propiedad) grants legal title to the property, while usufruct (usufructo) grants the right of use, enjoyment, and obtaining income.
• The usufructuary can rent out the property independently, but such contract will automatically terminate upon their death according to the LAU.
• The calculation of the value of both rights is carried out officially through the rule of 89, directly linked to the age of the usufructuary.
• Ordinary repairs and current expenses correspond to the usufructuary; extraordinary works and structural derramas correspond to the bare owner.
• The sale of bare ownership is an excellent financial tool for those over 65 years of age, exempt from IRPF taxation if it is their primary residence.

General legal information, not personalised legal advice. For your specific situation, ask your question for free at AbogadoAI — answers grounded in Spanish law (BOE), in English.

This is general information, not legal advice. Verify on the BOE or consult a lawyer for your specific case.